Wednesday, November 11, 2026

The Triple A's

 

“You can’t have a large nuclear war of the kind we have . . .  spent trillions of dollars preparing for where the victims in that war would be limited to the adversaries or any particular adversary . . .”   —Daniel Ellsberg, “An Ordinary Insanity”

The Democrats are gearing up to be laser-focused on Affordability and Accountability, but they should think seriously about adding a third “A”: Apocalypse.

The Blue Tsunami allows us to begin to speak more openly among ourselves about what has been repressed in our national consciousness—a vague anxiety and helplessness only half-acknowledged because it is so uncomfortable.  

Of the many reasons we feel uneasy about the arrogance and narcissism of officials like the President and the Secretary of Defense is their connection with vast numbers of nuclear weapons. Our anxiety is further intensified by the similar arrogance and narcissism of Mr. Putin, who has his own direct connection with infernal destructive power. Many scientists who worked at Los Alamos to make the first bomb were able to rationalize their anxiety about what they were doing by their fear that Hitler would get one first. Now we face a Hitler-like figure who possesses not one but thousands of warheads. Russia, or at least its ruthless totalitarian leadership, has tragically become Reagan’s “evil empire” again, 40 years after the end of the Cold War.

What can we do? What should we do?

One of late great Daniel Ellsberg’s last gifts of truth-telling was his recorded testimony just before he died, on the evil and insanity of one specific part of our nation’s—and Russia’s, and now China’s—deterrence system: Intercontinental Ballistic Missiles. Ellsberg is featured in two films, “An Ordinary Insanity,” available free on Youtube, and Paul Jay’s feature-length documentary, “How to Stop a Nuclear War,” due out in early 2028.

Ellsberg clearly defines our craziness (by “our” one might as well include Russia or any nuclear nation with ballistic capability): unlike our submarines, which are undetectable, and our bombers, which can be recalled, our ICBMs are fixed targets, their precise locations known. If, through malign intention or inadvertence, ICBMs anywhere were launched, the clock would start ticking and leaders would be thrust into the worst imaginable twenty minutes in human history: missiles incoming, bent on destroying our own missiles. Should we launch our own against their sites before we lose ours altogether? What if the attack turns out to be a mistake? This has happened more than once. Missiles cannot be recalled. Intended to protect us, ICBMs are destabilizing, an accident waiting to happen, a weapon that is meant never to be used but is kept endlessly ready to be instantly used. And the biggest lie of all is that our weapons are only for defense and therefore good, where their weapons are offensive and therefore bad. Is an ICBM an offensive or a defensive weapon? Once the button is pushed, does it matter? In the immortal words of singer-songwriter Tom Lehrer, “We’ll all go together when we go. . .”

So, one thing we can do is aggressively initiate talks about standing down everyone’s ICBMs, because it is in all countries’ interest. The situation is sufficiently dangerous that even if the United States stood down its ICBMs unilaterally, there would be a net gain in security for everyone, adversaries included. And in a nuclear world, it really is better for your adversaries to feel secure.

Instead, in monstrously stupid move, and with a monstrously gigantic amount of money, the U.S. has decided not to stand down, but to modernize its ICBMs. Why?

Follow the money. There are no limits to stupid policies when they are helpful to the bottom line of companies like Northrop Grumman, the principal modernization contractor for the Sentinel missile designated to replace the Minuteman, who are shamelessly willing undertake the work of the devil.

ICBM modernization is expected to cost 141 billion in today’s dollars, and climbing. Legislators from four states containing missile silos, Montana, North Dakota, Wyoming and Utah, are part of a group called the Senate ICBM Coalition. Eleven major Sentinel contractors contributed approximately $87 million to congressional candidates over four election cycles. Those contractors spent approximately $226 million on lobbying over the same period, employing 275 lobbyists. The eight senators in the ICBM Coalition had collectively received more than $443,000 from Sentinel contractors since 2018.

It turns out that there is an all too close relationship between the first two A’s and the third: the ICBM lobby is yet another group that needs to Account for its actions to U.S, voters, because we can’t Afford to improve our mass transit and electrical grid and our schools if we continue to mindlessly prepare for Apocalypse. Let those senators hear from you!

Monday, November 2, 2026

The Sixth Youth Nuclear Peace Summit: An American Perspective


High school students from Canada and from as far away as Japan gathered at the spectacular Canadian Museum for Human Rights to share their thoughts on the challenge of preventing nuclear war. Called “The Moral Responsibility of Humanity,” this was the sixth iteration of the Youth Nuclear Peace Summit, the brainchild of some extraordinary citizens of Winnipeg, including prominent attorney and David G. Newman K.C., retired school principal Estelle Lamoureux, and Kawser Ahmed, Executive Director of the Conflict and Resilience Research Center of Canada.

I was invited to participate in the conference as a former high school teacher and sometime writer on global issues. My impressions are entirely my own and do not reflect the views of my generous hosts or the staff of the various institutions that made the Summit possible.

Recently retired Parliamentarian Marilou McPhedran made the point in her talk to the students that we adults too often throw up our hands and say to the youth, “We failed; now it’s up to you,” an unfair delegation of survival tasks that remain intergenerational and, for that matter, international. Canada and the United States are geographically, militarily, environmentally, and morally interdependent. Neither country can achieve genuine security in isolation from the other. We’re all in this together, regardless of age or experience.

In private conversation Marilou also told me politely but firmly that Canadians know a lot about America and Americans don’t know very much about Canada. Point taken.

For example, progressive Americans romanticize Mr. Carney’s level-headed pushback against bizarre tariffs and even more bizarre visions of the outright annexation of your huge country. But it didn’t take long to understand that Canadians want accountability from their Prime Minister just as much as Americans want accountability from our hapless, narcissistic president (soon, fervently do we hope, to be at least somewhat declawed).

At the Summit, accountability naturally focused on nuclear issues, not only nuclear weapons but the entire nuclear fuel cycle. Indigenous participants, including Métis Elder Billie Schibler, made sure we were aware of the threats that both uranium mining and nuclear waste repositories pose to Indigenous lands and ecosystems. In addition, we explored the continued interdependence of Canada’s security—or lack thereof—with the security of the United States. This involves a fair amount of complex history which, in my amateur recounting, might further demonstrate American ignorance of Canada, but, in brief:

Prime Minister Carney may want to work toward increased security and defense independence from the U.S., but U.S. early-warning installations and infrastructure, which have required continuous upgrading as the arms race accelerates, have occupied Canadian soil for many decades. This raises an obvious but fundamental question: Can a country meaningfully retain independent control over its security choices when its geography makes it indispensable to a superpower’s defense? Canada must weigh the benefits of collective security agreements against the risks of deep integration with a much more powerful, and for the moment potentially unreliable, nuclear-armed neighbor.

The Youth Summit included previews of a powerful new documentary to be released in 2028 called “How To Stop a Nuclear War.” At the core of the film is the last testimony of the dying 90-year-old activist Daniel Ellsberg, who focused with laser moral force on the destabilizing effect of the land-based ICBMs not far south of the Canadian border. William Perry, Secretary of Defense under Bill Clinton, asserted that the U.S. could afford to stand down these weapons and that doing so would result in a net increase in everyone’s security. Instead, at breathtakingly vast expense, the U.S. is hell-bent on upgrading them.

President Trump’s vague fantasies of a “Golden Dome” of defensive, shoot-a-bullet-with-a-bullet antimissiles further blur the already unstable distinction between offensive and defensive weapons. The fundamental problem is that defensive systems can encourage an adversary to increase its offensive capabilities, while potentially giving the defending country a false sense of security.

And ultimately, what does Canada, or the U.S. for that matter, gain from even the most up-to-date early-warning system? In the unlikely event of a nuclear missile attack from Russia, the U.S. will have fifteen or twenty minutes to contemplate our own annihilation, including making the decision to use our own missiles before we lose them, thereby doubling the degree of mass death. Fallout or nuclear winter would, of course, engulf Canada along with everyone else worldwide.

It’s all pretty insane and heavy-duty stuff to lay on teens, but their presentations were creative, concise, soberly reflective, and hopeful. The cliché would be to say that our future is in good hands. But the challenges for all of us, old and young, are immense. One takeaway was that in looking at the uranium mining and nuclear waste issue alongside the nuclear war issue, we see yet one more way in which peacebuilding and environmental sustainability are interwoven.

I appreciated my new Canadian friends, especially their forbearance of our present American derangement. I was awed by the cathedral-like quality of the Canadian Museum for Human Rights and the powerful witness to the planet-wide struggle for compassion and justice its exhibits display. Most of all, I felt the poignant weight settling upon the teen participants as they struggled with the hard fact that the great powers haven’t yet figured out a way to global security that doesn’t involve perching on the razor’s edge of apocalypse.