Every man, woman and child lives under a nuclear sword of Damocles, hanging by the slenderest of threads, capable of being cut at any moment by accident, or miscalculation, or by madness. The weapons of war must be abolished before they abolish us.
—John F. Kennedy, U.N. Speech, 1961
In1984, when I started volunteering for the organization Beyond War, it was not so difficult to gather an audience in a living room and have a dialogue about the obsolescence of war.
The horror of the Cuban Missile Crisis of 1962 had not yet faded.
Short-range tactical nuclear weapons were proliferating on both sides of the Iron Curtain. Most citizens were willing to entertain the notion that not only could no one win a full-scale nuclear war, but there were three lesser levels of war that humans had to prevent: even a limited nuclear war could bring on “nuclear winter.” A conventional war could bring in the nuclear powers. Even small “local” conflicts could escalate into general conventional war and then upward to the nuclear level. War, all war, was a potential extinction machine. It still is.
To everyone’s immense surprise, the Soviet empire imploded five years later. When it did dissolve, thousands of peace activists assumed their job was done, and looked forward to the “peace dividend” sure to ensue.
In 2011, the number of nuclear countries has risen to nine. Pakistan and India repeat the folly of the U.S.-Soviet rivalry. Will Pakistan remain stable enough to keep its warheads from falling into the wrong hands? Will the generals in charge of them now, both in Pakistan and in India, act with restraint? Jonathan Schell asserts that the potential of a nuclear weapon being used against people is greater than it has been at any time since 1945. The thread holding up Kennedy’s Sword of Damocles has further attenuated.
Yawns of indifference. Nuclear war, accidental or deliberate, just isn’t a front burner issue for people. Whatever grabs our attention today seems far more indefinite than what grabbed us in 1984, while the demands for that attention are a hundred times more diverse. We are “distracted from distraction by distraction,” as Eliot wrote sixty years before the advent of e-mail.
When we do look up from our laptops and IPhones, we cannot avoid the interconnection of all our major challenges. Pull on any string in the gigantic ball of issues, and the unraveling reveals how densely tangled each issue is with all the others. The ingredients of nuclear weapons derive from the operation of nuclear power plants. These plants are themselves potential terrorist targets. At the same time they hold out hope for reliable non-CO2-emitting energy, when natural disasters or human errors do not overwhelm their safeguards.
The growing population of the earth demands a higher standard of living, even if providing it will overshoot—has already overshot—the carrying capacity of the planet. Meanwhile the United States military, the presumed guardian of the vaunted U.S. standard of living, is the biggest user of unrenewable fossil fuels on earth. One economic fact stands out: our military budget contains a great many more zeros in it than the total amount it would take to resolve the very challenges that will almost inevitably be the causes of future wars: the global provision of safe drinking water, birth control, medical care, nourishing food, education.
Why are our representatives unable to act upon such urgent yet beneficial measures of prevention? We need look no further than the behavior of the U.S. congress during the recent speech by the head of a foreign government.
Yanked by invisible strings, the entire joint session rose twenty-seven times to applaud unanimously. Was the speech really that eloquent? The point is not the power of the Israel lobby, but a more general one: the insidious pressure of the herd instinct. The puppetry comes from our dislike of making an independent assessment of reality and responding autonomously. Instead we look left and right for cues, fearful of being perceived as disloyal.
But we the people still hold the string that can lead us out of our labyrinth. One model is Tahrir Square in Egypt, where the peaceful involvement of hundreds of thousands forced positive structural change in a matter of weeks. Until Americans start flexing the unused muscle of citizen activism, the nuclear sword, the climate change sword, the global starvation sword and all the other swords will go on hanging above us by the thinnest of threads.
Labels don't help much.
We're too quick to define the conservative through the images of the Bush administration and the Teabaggers, which are like a form of tunnel vision. The word itself is loaded, whether it's being use by a self-defined conservative or one who is attempting to define a conservative. I liked the examples of conservatives in the article who are/were against reckless foreign intervention. Ironically, there are groups of self-described progressives who are cheering on the Afghanistan invasion, excuse my politically incorrect but accurate designation. And yes, knee jerking is not a trait exclusive to ilk like Teabaggers but very readily observable in some left-leaning online postings
Thanks for the centrist views, but no thanks.
The difference between you and I - a stalwart progressive - is that I never would have honored Reagen for doing one good thing amid the many bad things he said and did.
This isn't kindergarden. What you do with bad kids is remove them from the classroom, temporarily or permanently, so the rest of the class can move on.
And as for your snarky comment that progressives outght to get off their high horse, that makes about as much sense as me telling Senator Jeff Sessions to cut the drawl out of his speeches.
What you need a little more of is respect, for those who disagree with you.
Nationalism is not terrorism. And an adversary is not an enemy.
Stalwart Progressive?
While I understand your view, I look at the anti-war, pro-peace movement and do not see a lot of success.
We are excluding Middle American and traditional conservative views.
War is so ugly, so damaging to human life, national security, world stability, rule of law, undermining our economy . . . that we need to get serious about ending it. At least making sure the U.S. stops the ongoing wars of aggression, i.e. wars when we are not attacked and there is no UN resolution allowing it. We are constantly committing war crimes.
I'm an ardent progressive as well. But, I can see alliances with people on some issues and not on others which is why I was quoted in the article advocating for a re-start of the anti-war movement and making sue it is broad based and inclusive of all those who oppose war.
We need an effective peace movement and I can't see that if we exclude many, perhaps most, Ameicans who oppose war because of a progressive purity test.
Kevin Zeese www.ProsperityAgenda.US www.VotersForPeace.US
There are "Conservatives" and there are "conservatives"
The author, Winslow Myers, is taking a typical Coordinator Class, academic variety, approach to his subject.
It is true that many thoughtful Conservatives are amenable to cutting Defense Department budgets, lessening the influence and power of the military-industrial complex and rolling back the American Empire, the above mentioned Andrew Bacevich being one and Chalmers Johnson being another. What Mr. Myers does not take into account is the vast majority of self-identified "conservatives," the so-called teabaggers, fervently hold to the belief that government's primary function is maintaining a military, the police and the courts; the free market will take care of every other human want and need.
This Randian-Friedmanite belief system, i.e. government limited only to carrying out its coercive powers, is really at the root of the tea party movement. Had Mr. Myers asked any rank-and-file teabaggers if it is O.K. for a president to send their own and other Americans' children off to fight and die in foreign military adventures they would answer in the affirmative.
ET Spoon
Divide conservatives
No doubt there are many consevatives, especially of the neo-con variety, that support war, but there are also many who oppose war and militarism. They believe in real national defense, not the kind of military aggression the U.S. currently practices. Why not pull those conservatives to our side?
It will be easier for progressive or liberal anti-war Dems to oppose war if they can point to conservatives who are speaking out against war. It will make them stronger. It will be a defense to the attack from pro-war conservatives. They can say but A B anc C conservative aggress with me.
And, it will make it more likely that anti-war conservatives in Congress speak out and vote against war. We need a winning coalition to stop the war machine. It is no easy task, but it can be done if we get serious about it.
Kevin Zeese www.ProsperityAgenda.US www.VotersForPeace.US
left and right populism
Excellent piece. I disagree with the idea that you cannot recognize good things done by flawed people. The fundamental divides that separate ledft vs right populism are Environment, race and cultural pride. The Right needs to get over its reflexive anti-environmentalism. Republicans used to see no contradiction between Conservatism and conservationism but today we have people all convinced that en vironmentalism is a commie plot. The Left nees to understand that rural white Protestantism is a distinct culture worthy of existing with pride, just like any other culture. It seems like the left and right populists agree on much though. The coalition of Big Business and Big Governemtn is offensive to both.A coalition might be possible, but there are big philosophical diffeferences.
Defining war is not so easy for many on the Left..
The Democrats are now divided among several camps: the Moderates are primarily all the pro-Israeli hardliners who routinely support war and believe in militarism; the somewhat hawkish true Democrats like myself who do believe in nationalism and waging targeted battles like the Afghan Pakistan border or to prevent excessive brutality anywhere; and then we have the all out anti-war types. The last two make up all of the Progressives.
The Republicans on the other hand begin with a hard-core belief in militarism and to be perfectly honest, white superiority. The vast majority are pro-war and would launch any war on an as needed basis, whether it's for oil or lumber. They easily draw over all the moderate hardliners of the Left for most defense related votes, unfortunately.
I can appreciate your efforts to change things, epecially on the Right.. Ron Paul has a hell of time converting anyone from the Right, other than some of the younger generations. But as long as money, power and resources continue to become more out of reach than ever to the average citizen, we face a slew of hardliners ready to start wars and out of the rubble nationalists are born, willing to fight to the finish against them to protect what little they have left.
Nationalism is not terrorism. And an adversary is not an enemy.